Page 1 2 3 4

Traditional and Non-Traditional Karate

Qn:
What do you think of sport karate and contemporary wushu?

Ans:
I think sport karate and contemporary wushu have their places, if looking "cool" and flashy is what you want. It is a good way to promote the arts to the uninitiate. Contemporary wushu was created by the communist Chinese so that they can control the real martial artists. It is sad to see the traditional styles are being systematically destroyed by these low lifes.

On the other hand, several of the traditional internal masters I have had the good fortune to learn were from China. It is comforting to know that the traditional systems are still alive and well, albeit the numbers are smaller then they were.

Qn:
Since Bruce Lee was and remains perhaps the major influential figure in the eclectic martial arts movement,
what do you think of his fighting arts legacy?

Ans:
I think Bruce Lee was not the first or last one to train in multiple styles and arts. In the old days, the Chinese martial artists had learned and trained with whomever they could.

For example, the Xingyi and Baqua people always practice both styles together; in Wingchun, the staff form (Six and a half staff) was not originally a Wingchun form.

In fact, one of the thing I noticed since I started training in kungfu is that kungfu practitioners are always fluent in at least two to three and sometimes more styles.

I think Bruce Lee was a innovator. He felt the inadequacy of Wingchun in some areas and decided to correct it for his own use, and quite successfully.

However, I think his major fighting skill was still based on the Wingchun system, especially his "chi sou" (sticky hands) skill.

Most martial arts students only see what he did on his films and say that Bruce Lee was a great kicker (which he was), a good nanchaku fighter, but a lot of them fail to see that his sticky hands skill was his main fighting arsenal.

I think his fighting arts legacy shows students that they should learn/see as many styles as they can and take the key of each style/art to better their own skill, and, to be a good all round martial artist, which Bruce Lee was, you have to open up your eyes and see, adapt other styles for your own use.

*Suzuki Sensei and some of his senior students make special trips to Okinawa in June 1960, and May 1961 to learn and train with Grandmaster Miyasato.

Conducted by Mathieu Ravignat, senior member of the Gloucester Traditional Karate Association. February 2001 Ottawa, Canada
Copyright © Mathieu Ravignat 2001

TOP

Page 1 2 3 4

 
   
   
   
Articles on Karate The Kobudo of Hokama Tetsuhiro Information on the Wakefield Traditional Karate Club Links and Recommended Reading Back to the Home Page